The call never comes at a convenient time. A tenant rings, voice breaking, to say the house is on fire. Or worse, the call does not come at all and the manager discovers days later that a tenant has died quietly in a flat that was meant to be just another line on a rent roll.
These are the kinds of moments property investors prefer not to think about. They do not appear on glossy yield projections or bank calculators. Yet they are the situations that test the strength of a landlord’s systems, the clarity of their insurance cover, and most of all their instinct for human decency.
Sara Mitchell of Harcourts Reforma has lived through more than her share of these “stranger than fiction” scenarios. In her conversation with APIA TV, she strips away the comforting idea that property management is simply about maintenance schedules and market rent. Instead, she sketches a landscape where catastrophe is always a tenant’s phone call away.
What the Stories Reveal
The pattern is unsettling. Everyday life, a pan of chips left on the stove or a vape left charging on a desk, tilts suddenly into crisis. The law, in its dry precision, tells you what you must do: who can end a tenancy, how quickly, what notice periods apply. But the law cannot tell you how to face a mother standing outside her damaged home with a baby on her hip.
Mitchell’s point is sharp: this business runs on more than compliance. It requires preparation, documentation, and a willingness to act with compassion when rules alone feel inadequate.
Lessons for Investors
- Insurance only works if you do the groundwork. Quarterly inspections with photos are not just box-ticking, they are the evidence insurers demand when the unthinkable happens.
- Compassion has commercial value. Tenants remember who helped them when they had nowhere else to go. Owners notice when their managers handle disaster with grace. In a competitive rental market, that matters.
- Policies should anticipate human error. Clear clauses around safe charging or fire safety may feel redundant until they save you from a dispute with both tenant and insurer.
Why It Matters Now
In an era when rental yields are tight and regulatory burdens high, it is tempting for investors to focus only on cash flow. Mitchell’s cases remind us that resilience comes from another source: readiness for the rare but devastating event. You do not get to choose when a property turns into a crisis. You only get to choose how prepared you are to respond.
Watch the Full Conversation
For landlords and managers who want more than survival, who want to be respected as professionals in moments of chaos, the full video is essential viewing. Mitchell does not sugar-coat. She offers practical steps, legal clarity, and a candid look at the human side of property management.
Watch here: Stranger than Fiction – How to Deal with Unexpected Chaos at Your Rental Property
Add Comment